You are currently viewing When to Replace Your Toilet | 3 noticeable signs to look for

When to Replace Your Toilet | 3 noticeable signs to look for

Understanding the right time to replace a toilet is important. You do not want to sit down, dropping your kids off at the pool when all of a sudden you feel a crack appear. Not only is this crack inconvenient, it might pinch your cheeks resulting in a questionable feeling. Not that we’ve had this exact experience before. We’re just saying.

You should replace your toilet when it’s older than 25 years old. Even when the toilet is just working fine, it probably uses a lot more water than it should. Opt for a newer model that conserves water. Not only is this better for the environment, but it is also better for your wallet.

Keep reading to find out 3 signs that tell you it’s time to replace your personal throne!

How do you know when a toilet needs to be replaced?

Toilets are sturdy fixtures in our homes, but they don’t last forever. Recognizing when it’s time to replace a toilet can save homeowners from future headaches and potential water damage.

The following issues may be signs to replace your toilet:

  • Your toilet is too old to be efficient
  • The internal workings of your toilet are worn
  • Hairline fractures are starting to appear

Let’s dive into them!

1. Your toilet is older than 25 years old

One telltale sign is age. If the toilet is more than 25 years old, it might be time for an upgrade. Even if it seems to be working fine- newer models are more efficient, which means savings on water bills.

Ever wondered about the life expectancy of your toilet? Here you can read all about your toilet’s lifespan.

Consider also the comfort and aesthetics—if the current toilet wobbles, no longer match bathroom renovations, or isn’t comfortable, a replacement can be an opportunity for an upgrade. Be proactive about evaluating the condition of the toilet; it’s a key step to ensuring the comfort, safety, and efficiency of a home.

2. Worn internal workings

Another clear indicator is persistent clogging. Nobody enjoys dealing with a clog, but if it’s becoming a regular occurrence, this could be a sign of worn internal workings or a design that’s not up to the task.

Frequent repairs are another red flag. If fixing the toilet has become an item on the monthly to-do list, it’s probably more cost-effective to invest in a new one. Up-to-date models have improved flush mechanisms and are less prone to requiring parts replacements or repairs.

3. Hairline fractures

Last but definitely not least, check for cracks. Hairline fractures in the tank or bowl may not seem like emergencies, but these can lead to leaks and severe water damage over time. A crack will only worsen, and it’s wise to deal with it promptly.

when toilet replace

Photo by jankolar on Unsplash

Do toilets wear out over time?

Toilets can experience wear and tear over time. Continuous usage, exposure to water, and the effects of cleaning agents can contribute to the gradual deterioration of a toilet’s components. Common issues include the wearing out of flush valves, flappers, and seals, which can lead to leaks or inefficient flushing.

Additionally, mineral deposits and sediment accumulation may affect the toilet’s performance. While toilets are durable fixtures, regular maintenance and timely replacement of worn-out parts can extend their lifespan and prevent more significant issues in the long run.

However, it is still recommended to upgrade to a newer model once your toilet is older than 25 years old.

21 fun facts about your toilet you’ve never heard before

Pro’s of upgrading your toilet

Considering the strides made in modern plumbing technology, there’s more to the story of upgrading to a new toilet model than one might initially think.

One of the top advantages of modern toilets is the range of features designed for enhanced hygiene and ease of cleaning. Touchless flush models, for instance, not only reduce the spread of germs but also advance a more sanitary bathroom environment.

Antimicrobial surfaces in newer models hinder bacteria growth, making the space cleaner and reducing the need for frequent deep cleanings.

Other advancements in toilet technology

Investing in a new toilet can benefit those with mobility concerns. Modern toilets offer varied height options, meeting ADA compliance for universal use. Comfort height toilets, slightly taller than older models, are especially helpful for mobility issues. They create an inclusive and user-friendly bathroom.

Additionally, newer designs seamlessly integrate into the bathroom’s aesthetic, providing a sleek and contemporary look.

In essence, opting for a new toilet model extends beyond water savings and operational reliability—it’s about embracing the advancements that enhance overall bathroom hygiene, accessibility, and design.

when toilet replace

Professional toilet installation vs. DIY

When contemplating whether to hire a professional or replace a toilet oneself, one must weigh:

  • The practicality
  • Cost of doing it yourself vs professionally
  • One’s own skill level

For those less experienced in the art of plumbing, it can be a real gamble to undertake a toilet installation.

It’s not just about connecting pieces; it’s important to ensure a proper seal to avoid leaks, properly align the toilet to existing plumbing, and ensure the stability and functionality of the installation.

Neglecting these aspects may cause water damage or ongoing maintenance issues that could have been avoided with professional help.

On the other side of the plunger, those with some DIY prowess may find replacing a toilet to be a satisfying project.

Installing a toilet yourself

With a plethora of step-by-step guides and video tutorials available, a confident homeowner can potentially save on labor costs.

However, it’s paramount to keep in mind that if mistakes are made, it could cost more in the long run to rectify missteps.

Furthermore, disposing of an old toilet can be a cumbersome task, one that professionals typically handle as part of their service.

Before making the decision, consider the value of time, the guarantee of work done right, and peace of mind in knowing that a professional will navigate any unexpected plumbing challenges that might arise.

Although there’s pride in completing a DIY project, sometimes leaning on the expertise of a plumber can ensure the transformation of the bathroom experience is seamless and stress-free, without the potential pitfalls of a less-than-perfect self-installation.

Cost considerations for toilet replacement

So how much does it cost to replace toilet?

The price range for new toilets varies significantly, with basic models starting as low as $100 and high-end, feature-rich toilets climbing to $1000 or more. When it comes time to replace a toilet, homeowners face a big decision regarding the type of toilet to install, the actual costs involved, and the decision to do it themselves or professionally.

In discussing expenses, one must consider the materials and tools needed for installation. For instance, a new wax ring, supply lines, and bolts are typically required. These materials are modestly priced but essential for a proper setup.

Finally, if the job requires hiring a professional plumber, expect the labor cost to be a significant part of the overall expense. The region and complexity of the job heavily influence this cost, ranging from around $150 to $400+.

But remember, investing in professional installation can save money by preventing costly mistakes and future repairs. Balancing upfront costs with long-term benefits will lead to a wise investment and a hassle-free toilet replacement.

Photo by curology on Unsplash

Embracing the new wave of toilet technology not only contributes to a better environment but also enhances our overall quality of life at home. Remember, the bathroom is a sanctuary of comfort, and with the right toilet, it can also symbolize our commitment to sustainability and modern living.

Disclaimer: is not responsible for any damage caused to your toilet and surroundings by (wrongly) interpreting information found on this site. Please seek custom advice from a professional to evaluate your current situation.

This article may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you. AF links help support this blog so that it can exist and expand for years to come!